A Controversial Call Sparks Debate in the Surabaya Derby
The recent clash between Persebaya Surabaya and Madura United, dubbed the “Derby Suramadu,” was marred by a contentious refereeing decision that has ignited a firestorm of criticism.
During the match, which took place on Monday, February 28th, 2022, Persebaya’s Samsul Arif was brought down inside Madura United’s penalty area by Fachruddin Aryanto. The incident, clearly visible in video replays, should have resulted in a penalty kick for Persebaya. However, referee Agus Fauzan inexplicably failed to award the penalty, much to the dismay of Persebaya players and fans alike.This controversial call has drawn widespread condemnation, with many questioning Agus Fauzan’s judgment and impartiality. The perceived bias against Persebaya has led to accusations that the referee’s decision significantly impacted the outcome of the match.
Adding fuel to the fire, Surabaya’s mayor, Eri Cahyadi, publicly weighed in on the controversy. Through his Instagram account (@ericahyadi_), Cak Eri expressed his hope for improved officiating in future matches, subtly criticizing the referee’s performance without directly naming him.
Despite the controversy surrounding the refereeing, Persebaya Surabaya ultimately emerged victorious, securing a 2-1 win over madura United. Goals from Bruno Moreira and Alie sesay propelled Persebaya to victory, while Beto Goncalves scored Madura United’s lone goal from a penalty kick.
A Ticking Time Bomb? Refereeing Decisions & Teh Passion of the “Derby Suramadu”
welcome back, sports fans! Today, we’re diving headfirst into a controversy that’s ignited passions and sparked heated debates among Indonesian football enthusiasts – the contentious refereeing call that overshadowed the recent “Derby Suramadu” clash between Persebaya Surabaya and Madura United.
Joining us to dissect this controversial incident is none other than legendary Indonesian footballer, Bambang Pamungkas, affectionately known as “Bepe” to his legions of fans.Bepe, welcome to the show!
Bepe: thanks for having me. It’s always a pleasure to discuss the beautiful game, especially when it comes to a rivalry as intense as the “Derby Suramadu.”
Moderator: Absolutely, Bepe. Now, let’s get straight to the heart of the matter. This alleged missed penalty call against Madura United has caused quite a stir. What are your thoughts on the incident itself?
Bepe: Look, from what I saw in the replays, it was a clear penalty. samsul Arif was brought down inside the box. There’s no denying that.
Moderator: So, you believe the referee made a clear error in judgment?
Bepe: I wouldn’t say it was necessarily an error in judgment; referees are human and make mistakes. But the call, from my personal perspective, did go against the clear evidence.
Moderator: That’s fascinating. Persebaya ultimately won the match,2-1. do you think this controversial call ultimately affected the outcome of the game?
Bepe: It’s tough to say for sure. Football is a game of fine margins. Perhaps Persebaya would have scored from the penalty and won more comfortably. Maybe Madura United would have rallied and equalized. We’ll never know.
moderator: The incident has certainly sparked a lot of discussion about officiating standards in Indonesian football. Surabaya’s mayor, Eri Cahyadi, even voiced his concerns about the need for better officiating. What are your thoughts on this?
Bepe: It’s encouraging to see influential figures like Mayor Cahyadi speaking about this issue. We need to ensure our referees are properly trained and equipped to make the right calls, especially in high-stakes matches like the “Derby Suramadu.”
Moderator: Absolutely. The passion surrounding this derby is undeniable.Do you think this heightened atmosphere might put extra pressure on referees?
Bepe: It’s possible. The “Derby Suramadu” is always a fiercely contested affair.
The atmosphere is electric, and emotions run high. Referees need to be strong and impartial, able to make tough decisions without being swayed by external pressure.
Moderator: Opinions on the refereeing call have been polarized. Some fans believe it was a clear mistake, while others argue that it was a judgment call. What message would you send to fans who feel strongly about this incident?
Bepe: It’s crucial to remember that everyone is entitled to their opinion. Let’s keep the discussion respectful and focus on the love of the game. The “Derby Suramadu” is a celebration of football, and we should celebrate the passion and rivalry while also respecting the officials who officiate these matches.
Moderator: Wise words,Bepe. Thank you for sharing your insights wiht us today.
Bepe: My pleasure.
Moderator: Now, I want to open the floor to our audience. What are your thoughts on this controversial penalty call? Was it a clear error, a arduous judgment call, or something else entirely? Let us know in the comments below!
