The 2024 Major League Baseball season is coming to a close, but for the New York Yankees, the real battle is about to begin: free agent season. Regardless of how their current season concludes, it is clear that the Yankees’ infield configuration will undergo significant changes by the start of next season. With Anthony Rizzo and Gleyber Torres facing free agency, rumors of possible signings are intensifying, and one of the biggest names to emerge is Houston Astros star Alex Bregman.
A New Beginning in the Infield
The Yankees’ immediate future in the infield is uncertain. The decision not to exercise Rizzo’s team option, combined with Torres’ likely departure, leaves a void that must be addressed. The first base position, which could be filled by a new player, and the move of Jazz Chisholm Jr. to second base are adjustments that are being discussed, but the key lies in who will occupy third base. Bregman, with his impressive track record, appears as an ideal option.
Bregman’s Impact on the Yankees
Alex Bregman is not only known for his hitting ability, but also for his ability to elevate his team’s performance. However, his relationship with the Yankees is marked by controversy. The Astros’ famous sign-stealing scandal in 2017 cast a shadow over the player, especially at Yankee Stadium, where hostility toward the Astros has been palpable. In this context, Bregman faces a dilemma: can he build bridges with a fan base that still remembers the perceived betrayal?
A Problematic Relationship?
An article by Tim Kelly in Bleacher Report suggests that despite the “bad blood” between Bregman and the Yankees, the union could be beneficial. However, this complicated link could be an obstacle. In Kelly’s words, “if some bridges could be rebuilt, Bregman would be a great fit at third base for the Yankees in 2025.” The question remains, however: Will the Yankees be able to put aside the past to move toward the future?
Financial and Competitive Considerations
Another crucial factor in this equation is the financial aspect. Bregman is expected to command the most lucrative contract of all available infielders this season, possibly topping $100 million. However, the situation becomes complicated if the Yankees manage to retain Juan Soto, who is expected to sign a contract worth more than $500 million. This would create a scenario in which the Yankees would have to evaluate whether they can really afford to add Bregman to their roster.
Kelly also mentions that if Soto decided to join another team, such as the San Francisco Giants or New York Mets, the option of pivoting to Bregman could be on the table. However, the likelihood of that happening is uncertain, making Bregman’s future with the Yankees even more nebulous.
The Future of the Yankees: Strategy and Aspirations
The Yankees have been in a constant quest to return to the top of the MLB. Acquiring a player like Bregman could be a decisive step in this direction. His experience and leadership could complement the young energy of players like Chisholm Jr. and, potentially, Soto.
However, the Yankees must carefully consider their strategy. The pressure to win is high, and every decision counts. While Bregman represents an attractive addition, the recent history between him and the Yankees raises questions about what his reception by the fans and adaptation to the team would be like.
The New York Yankees are at a turning point. With the possibility of Alex Bregman being one of its cast, the organization faces a crucial decision that could redefine its future. The combination of talent, history and finances will make this offseason fascinating for fans and analysts alike. The Yankees must decide if the addition of Bregman is worth it, and if they can put the past behind them to embrace a promising future. Only time will tell if this is the right move for the Yankees in their quest for a championship.
