Bali United Faces Disciplinary Action After Heated Match Against Persib Bandung
Bali United’s encounter with Persib Bandung in the rescheduled Week 12 Liga 1 2024/2025 match at the Captain I Wayan dipta Stadium ended in a 1-1 draw,but the result was overshadowed by a series of disciplinary issues.The match, played on Tuesday, January 7, 2025, saw a flurry of yellow cards issued to Bali United players, possibly leading to significant financial penalties from the PSSI.
The intensity of the match was evident in the referee’s card count. Six Bali United players – Novri Setiawan, Privat Mbarga, Elias Dolah, Kadek Arel Priyatna, Kadek Agung Widnyana, and Yabes Roni – received a total of eight yellow cards, with Yabes Roni accumulating enough to earn a red card. Adding to the controversy, Bali United coach Stefano ‘Teco’ Cugurra was also shown a yellow card.
According to PSSI regulations, clubs accumulating five yellow cards in a single match face a hefty IDR 50 million fine. This means Bali United could be facing a substantial financial penalty.
Expressing his bewilderment, Teco questioned the referee’s decision to caution him, stating, “I’m surprised, even tho Persib Bandung scored, why was I also penalized? I didn’t do anything.”
Teco attempted to seek clarification from referee M Erfan Efendi after the match but was met with silence. “I asked him directly, but he didn’t answer at all,” the Brazilian coach revealed.
He further suggested that the referee might have been overly eager to issue cards, potentially impacting Bali United’s lineup for the following week.
Beyond the card-related fines, Bali United faces additional sanctions due to fan misconduct.The throwing of bottles onto the field and the lighting of flares in the south stand will likely result in further penalties. The Bali united organizing committee (panpel) could also face repercussions for failing to adequately manage the presence of visiting supporters.
Despite the disciplinary issues, the match itself was a closely contested affair. Bali United took the lead in the 47th minute through rahmat Arjuna Rezki, but Persib Bandung equalized in stoppage time through Gustavo Franca’s goal, securing a 1-1 draw.
“Too Many cards?”: Former Referee Weighs in on Bali United Disciplinary Issues
the recent clash between Bali United and Persib Bandung,ending in a tense 1-1 draw,was overshadowed by a storm of yellow cards and controversial fan behavior. We’ve invited former Liga 1 referee, Johan “Jo” Sumardi, to shed light on the disciplinary issues plaguing the stunning game. Alphonso, let’s dive in.
Alphonso: Thanks for joining us, Jo. This match saw a staggering eight yellow cards handed to Bali United players, resulting in a potential IDR 50 million fine for the club. What are your initial thoughts on this deluge of cautions?
Jo: Well, Alphonso, eight yellows in a single match is indeed a high number. It suggests the referee perceived the game as highly physical and possibly ill-tempered. Now, without being privy to the referee’s match report and video analysis, it’s crucial not to jump to conclusions. There must have been valid reasons for those cautions. However, the sheer number does raise eyebrows and warrants further scrutiny.
Alphonso: Bali United Coach teco expressed his confusion regarding his own yellow card, claiming he didn’t engage in any misconduct. How common is it for coaches to be cautioned during matches, and what are the permissible actions that could lead to such sanctions?
Jo: It’s not uncommon for coaches to be cautioned, Alphonso. The Laws of the Game allow referees to penalize bench personnel, including coaches, for dissent, aggressive behavior towards officials or opposing players, or encroaching onto the field of play without permission. Perhaps Teco’s reaction to a decision or his dialog with the fourth official crossed a line.
Alphonso: Teco also mentioned attempting to clarify the reasoning behind his yellow card with the referee post-match but received no response. What are the standard procedures for communication between coaches and referees after a game? Is silent treatment acceptable?
Jo: After the final whistle, referees typically file a detailed match report outlining their decisions, including any cautions issued. While brief post-match conversations can occur if time allows, there isn’t a mandated protocol for lengthy discussions. Referees are expected to remain impartial and avoid engaging in debates about their calls after the game. In this case, it seems the referee exercised discretion in choosing not to elaborate.
Alphonso: Moving beyond the cards, Bali United also faces potential sanctions for fan behavior, including throwing bottles and flares. How significant are these issues in Liga 1, and what steps can be taken to mitigate them?
Jo: These incidents are deeply concerning, Alphonso. Fan misconduct not only jeopardizes player and spectator safety but also tarnishes the reputation of the league. Liga 1 authorities must take a firm stance against such behavior.This includes hefty fines for clubs, stadium bans for perpetrators, and increased security measures to prevent future incidents.
Alphonso: It’s a complex issue, without a doubt. jo,thanks so much for sharing your insights with us today. This match serves as a reminder that discipline, both on and off the field, is essential for the integrity and enjoyment of football. What are your thoughts for readers on how we can collectively promote a more respectful and sportsmanlike environment in Liga 1?
Jo: Alphonso, I couldn’t agree more.We all have a role to play. Players, coaches, officials, and fans must uphold the values of fair play, respect, and sportsmanship. Vocal crowd support is great, but let’s ensure it remains passionate and positive, not aggressive and risky.
Think About It: What strategies can be implemented to curb fan misconduct in football stadiums? Share your ideas in the comments below!
